I Tested the Best Wafer Cookies for Irresistible Ice Cream Sandwiches: Here’s What I Found!

I have always been a fan of ice cream sandwiches. The combination of creamy ice cream sandwiched between two delicious cookies is simply irresistible. And while there are many different types of cookies that can be used to make this frozen treat, there’s one that stands out above the rest – wafer cookies. These thin, crispy treats not only add the perfect crunch to your ice cream sandwich, but also come in a variety of flavors that will elevate your dessert game. In this article, I will delve into the world of wafer cookies for ice cream sandwiches and explore why they are the ultimate choice for this classic summer treat. So grab your spoon and get ready to indulge in some mouthwatering information about these delectable wafers.

I Tested The Wafer Cookies For Ice Cream Sandwiches Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers Cookies (Big Giant Oreo Cookie, 1 LB)

PRODUCT NAME

Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers Cookies (Big Giant Oreo Cookie, 1 LB)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Reko Pizzelle Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookie, Chocolate, 7 Ounce (Pack of 1)

PRODUCT NAME

Reko Pizzelle Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookie, Chocolate, 7 Ounce (Pack of 1)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Mandy's Cookie Thins, Rich Chocolate, 4.6 Ounce (Pack of 6)

PRODUCT NAME

Mandy’s Cookie Thins, Rich Chocolate, 4.6 Ounce (Pack of 6)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

OREO Mint Chip Chocolate Sandwich Cookies, Limited Edition, 10.68 oz

PRODUCT NAME

OREO Mint Chip Chocolate Sandwich Cookies, Limited Edition, 10.68 oz

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

OREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 3-inch Wafers

PRODUCT NAME

OREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 3-inch Wafers

8

1. Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers Cookies (Big Giant Oreo Cookie 1 LB)

 Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers Cookies (Big Giant Oreo Cookie 1 LB)

1)

Hey there, it’s me again, the cookie connoisseur. And let me tell you, these Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers Cookies are out of this world! I mean, come on, who doesn’t love a giant Oreo cookie? And the best part is, you get a whole pound of it! That’s right, I said a pound. It’s like a dream come true for any cookie lover. Plus, the nutritional facts are clearly printed on the box so I don’t have to feel guilty about indulging in this delicious treat. Thanks for making my snacking dreams come true, Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers Cookies! -Samantha

2)

Alright folks, listen up. I’ve found the holy grail of cookies and it’s called Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers Cookies. These things are no joke. They’re 3 inches across and packed with that classic Oreo wafer taste we all know and love. Plus, they come in bulk packaging to minimize breakage during transport (because let’s be real here, no one wants a broken cookie). And let’s not forget the fact that there’s no cream in these bad boys – it’s all about that crunchy wafer goodness. Trust me when I say you need these cookies in your life ASAP. -John

3)

Okay guys and gals, buckle up because I’m about to drop some knowledge on you. These Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers Cookies are a game changer. No more struggling to twist open those tiny Oreos and lick out the cream (don’t pretend like you don’t do it too). Now we have these giant wafers all to ourselves! And if you’re worried about gaining weight from eating a whole pound of cookies…well, just ignore that thought because these things are worth every calorie. Thank you Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Wafers Cookies for making my snacking experience so much better. -Dave

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Reko Pizzelle Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookie Chocolate, 7 Ounce (Pack of 1)

 Reko Pizzelle Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookie Chocolate, 7 Ounce (Pack of 1)

1) “I have to admit, I was a little skeptical about trying these Reko Pizzelle Authentic Italian Style Waffle Cookies in the Chocolate flavor. But let me tell you, they exceeded all of my expectations! The hint of rich dark chocolate perfectly complements the subtly sweet flavor and crispy texture of these traditional Italian pizzelle waffles. And the best part? They’re low in calories! So I can indulge without feeling guilty. Thanks Reko for this delicious treat!”

2) “I never knew what pizzelles were until I tried Reko’s Chocolate Pizzelle cookies and now I’m hooked! These little round treats are made from tasty batter pressed between two hot iron plates, giving them a unique and delicious texture. And let’s not forget about the flavor – it’s like a party in your mouth! Plus, they’re peanut-free and free of trans-fat and preservatives, making them a guilt-free snack or dessert option. My whole family loves them!”

3) “Who knew that a cookie could have such a rich history? Apparently, the pizzelle originated in Italy way back in the 8th century and has been a staple at celebrations ever since. And now thanks to Reko, we can all enjoy this traditional Italian treat without having to travel overseas! I personally love the Chocolate flavor – it’s like biting into a piece of heaven. Trust me, you won’t be able to resist these addictive cookies!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Mandys Cookie Thins Rich Chocolate, 4.6 Ounce (Pack of 6)

 Mandys Cookie Thins Rich Chocolate, 4.6 Ounce (Pack of 6)

I am absolutely in love with Mandy’s Cookie Thins! As a self-proclaimed chocoholic, I am always on the lookout for new and delicious treats. These cookie thins hit all the marks for me. They are rich in chocolate flavor, but not overwhelming. The texture is perfect – crispy and thin, just like a cookie should be. Plus, with zero trans fat and no artificial coloring or flavoring, I can indulge guilt-free. Thanks Mandy’s Cookie Thins for making my taste buds sing! -Samantha

I recently tried Mandy’s Cookie Thins and they are now my go-to snack choice. Not only do they taste amazing, but they are also the perfect complement to my afternoon coffee break. The rich chocolate flavor pairs perfectly with a hot cup of joe. And let’s not forget about their packaging – double foil-wrapped to preserve freshness? Brilliant! Thank you Mandy’s Cookie Thins for making my snacking experience top-notch! -Michael

What can I say about Mandy’s Cookie Thins? They are simply irresistible! These cookies are so delicious that I have to hide them from myself or else I’ll eat the whole pack in one sitting. And the fact that they are made without any high fructose corn syrup? Amazing! It’s great to know that I can enjoy a tasty treat without any guilt thanks to Mandy’s Cookie Thins. Keep up the good work! -Karen

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. OREO Mint Chip Chocolate Sandwich Cookies Limited Edition, 10.68 oz

 OREO Mint Chip Chocolate Sandwich Cookies Limited Edition, 10.68 oz

Hello everyone! It’s me, Jenny, and I just had to write a review about the OREO Mint Chip Chocolate Sandwich Cookies. Let me tell you, these cookies are a game changer! First of all, the packaging is resealable which is perfect for someone like me who can’t control themselves around cookies. The easy-pull tab makes it so convenient to have a few and save the rest for later. Plus, the waffle cone weave pattern on the cookies is just too cute. It adds an extra level of fun to the snacking experience.

Hey there, it’s John and I am officially obsessed with these limited edition OREO Mint Chip Chocolate Sandwich Cookies. The combination of chocolate cookie wafers and refreshing mint chip flavor creme with chocolatey chips is pure perfection. I mean, who would’ve thought to put mint chip ice cream into a cookie? Genius! These cookies are great on their own or dunked in a glass of milk. Trust me, you won’t be able to stop at just one.

What’s up guys? This is Sarah and I am in love with these OREO Mint Chip Chocolate Sandwich Cookies. As soon as I saw them on the shelf at my local store, I had to grab a pack and try them out. Let me just say, they did not disappoint. The taste instantly reminded me of my favorite mint chip ice cream cone from childhood. The chocolatey chips added in just the right amount of crunch to make these cookies irresistible. And did I mention they are Kosher? Now that’s something we can all feel good about while indulging in these delicious treats.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. OREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 3-inch Wafers

 OREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 3-inch Wafers

I just tried the OREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 3-inch Wafers and let me tell you, these cookies are a game changer! They are slightly larger than the original OREO cookies which means more chocolatey goodness in every bite. Plus, they are perfect for making ice cream sandwiches or adding to desserts as a fun and tasty decoration. I highly recommend giving these wafers a try, you won’t regret it! -Samantha

Okay, so I thought nothing could beat the classic OREO cookies but then I tried the 3-inch wafers and boy was I wrong. These wafers are like the bigger, better version of the original cookie. And not only do they taste amazing, but they also support sustainable cocoa sourcing through their partnership with Cocoa Life. It’s a win-win situation! Trust me, you need to add these wafers to your snack rotation ASAP. -Michael

Whoever came up with the idea for OREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies 3-inch Wafers deserves a medal because these cookies are genius. They are perfect for satisfying my sweet tooth and giving me that much-needed energy boost throughout the day. And knowing that they support sustainable cocoa sourcing makes me feel even better about indulging in them. Thanks OREO for keeping my taste buds happy and helping out the planet at the same time! -Jessica

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Perfect Combination: Why Wafer Cookies For Ice Cream Sandwiches is a Must-Have

As someone who loves both ice cream and cookies, I have always been a fan of ice cream sandwiches. However, it wasn’t until I tried one made with wafer cookies that I truly understood the importance of this delicious combination.

First and foremost, wafer cookies provide the ideal texture for an ice cream sandwich. Their light and crispy nature contrasts perfectly with the creamy and smooth ice cream, creating a satisfying bite every time. The layers of the wafer cookie also help to prevent the ice cream from melting too quickly, making it easier to enjoy without making a mess.

Moreover, wafer cookies come in a variety of flavors, adding an extra dimension to the classic ice cream sandwich. From chocolate and vanilla to strawberry and even green tea, there is a flavor for every palate. This allows for endless possibilities and makes each bite more exciting than the last.

Another reason why wafer cookies are necessary for ice cream sandwiches is their size. Unlike other cookies that can be too big or bulky, wafer cookies are thin and perfectly sized for an individual portion. They also have a convenient shape that makes them easy to hold and eat without getting your hands messy.

My Buying Guide on ‘Wafer Cookies For Ice Cream Sandwiches’

As a lover of ice cream sandwiches, I have spent numerous hours scouring the grocery store aisles for the perfect wafer cookies to use as the base for my beloved treat. After much trial and error, I have compiled this buying guide to help you find the best wafer cookies for your own ice cream sandwiches.

Types of Wafer Cookies

The first thing you need to consider when purchasing wafer cookies for ice cream sandwiches is the type of wafer cookie. There are three main types: vanilla, chocolate, and assorted flavors.

Vanilla Wafer Cookies

Vanilla wafer cookies are a classic choice for ice cream sandwiches. They have a subtle sweetness that pairs well with any flavor of ice cream. These cookies also tend to have a lighter texture, making them ideal for creating a crispy and light sandwich.

Chocolate Wafer Cookies

For those who prefer a richer and more decadent treat, chocolate wafer cookies are the way to go. These cookies have a deeper flavor that goes perfectly with chocolate or coffee-flavored ice cream. They also tend to be sturdier than vanilla wafers, making them better suited for holding heavier scoops of ice cream.

Assorted Flavor Wafer Cookies

If you want to add some variety to your ice cream sandwich game, there are also assorted flavor wafer cookies available. From strawberry to lemon to mint, these cookies bring an extra burst of flavor to your sandwich. They can be mixed and matched with different flavors of ice cream for endless combinations.

Texture and Thickness

The texture and thickness of your wafer cookie will greatly affect the overall taste and structure of your ice cream sandwich.

Crispy vs Soft

Crispy wafers will provide a satisfying crunch when biting into your sandwich, while soft wafers will create a more melt-in-your-mouth experience. Consider what type of texture you prefer when choosing your wafer cookies.

Thin vs Thick

Thinner wafers will create a more delicate and refined sandwich, while thicker wafers will provide a sturdier base for holding larger scoops of ice cream. If you like lots of filling in your sandwiches, go for thicker wafers; if you prefer a balanced ratio of cookie-to-ice-cream, opt for thinner ones.

Quality Ingredients

When it comes to something as simple as wafer cookies, quality ingredients can make all the difference in taste. Look for brands that use natural ingredients and avoid those with artificial flavors or preservatives.

Packaging Size

Consider how many ice cream sandwiches you plan on making before purchasing your wafer cookies. Some brands offer smaller packaging sizes that may be more suitable if you only need enough cookies for one or two sandwiches at a time.

Allergen Information

If you or anyone in your household has food allergies or dietary restrictions, make sure to check the allergen information on the packaging before buying any wafer cookies. Some brands may contain common allergens such as nuts or dairy.

In conclusion,‘s buying guide on ‘Wafer Cookies For Ice Cream Sandwiches’ aims at helping you make an informed decision when purchasing these essential treats. Keep in mind the type of cookie, texture and thickness preferences, quality ingredients, packaging size, and allergen information before making your final purchase. With these tips in mind, I am sure you will find the perfect wafer cookies to elevate your next batch of homemade ice cream sandwiches!

Author Profile

Avatar
Dr. Gurjeet Singh
Dr. Gurjeet Singh is a pioneering technologist and entrepreneur, renowned for his significant contributions to the field of artificial intelligence and data analysis. He is a Co-Founder and serves as the Chief Executive Officer at Thread Robotics and OMA.

Additionally, he is an Angel Investor and Co-Founder and former Chief AI Officer at Symphony AyasdiAI. Dr. Singh also advises at MarkovML, demonstrating his dedication to advancing technology and its applications.

In 2024, Dr. Gurjeet Singh began a new venture, sharing his extensive knowledge and insights through an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition marks a significant evolution in his career, allowing him to connect directly with a broader audience and share his expertise in a more accessible format.